In this blog post, we will be analyzing a viral Facebook post written by Amanda Theresa, which has been circulating in the Christian community. The post includes several arguments commonly used against ex-Christians, and in this article, we will be taking a closer look at these arguments and exploring why they may not hold up under scrutiny. We will also be examining the various logical fallacies used in the post and discussing why they are problematic.

---

In today’s world, there is a wide range of belief systems, practices, and spiritual paths to choose from. From Christianity to New Age spirituality, people are searching for meaning and connection in their lives. The Argument Amanda presents is a logical fallacy of “Black-and-White Thinking” or “False Dichotomy.” This fallacy occurs when only two options are presented when in reality there are many more options available. Other faiths, atheism, and agnosticism do exist and offer far better answers than any of the fringe pseudo-scientific weirdness that she claims to have gotten into. With this said, at their core, many spiritual beliefs and practices can be seen as spiritual placebos – they have no real impact on the world, but they can bring comfort and a sense of peace to those who believe in them.

Personal choice and individual agency play a major role in spiritual practices and beliefs. Some may find comfort in the structure and community of organized religion, while others may find more meaning in alternative spiritual practices. Doing what Amanda does, presenting Christianity as the ONLY way to be saved, not only assumes that people need saved but makes it so that the vast majority of humans who ever lived are burning in hell, as they never even had the opportunity to hear her saving gospel.

---

The type of thinking we see in the post oversimplifies the complexity of human belief and reduces it to an either/or scenario, disregarding the nuance and variety of human experiences. By presenting this false dichotomy, the author is misleading their audience and making a flawed argument. It is important to challenge all belief systems, including those that supposedly come from a higher being. While it can be tempting to blindly accept the teachings of a particular faith or spiritual leader, it is essential to think critically and evaluate beliefs for oneself.